JIBS Summit · O.P. Jindal Global University15 October 2026

Five Questions to Ask Before You Trust an Assessment

From the talk “The New Science of Talent Assessment: From Potential to Possibility”

The one-page attendee handout: Five Questions to Ask Before You Trust an Assessment

Assessments add structure to hiring and talent decisions, but only when the evidence they produce is relevant, consistent and interpreted responsibly. Before you rely on one, ask these five questions.

Tarvinder KaurCo-Founder, PMaps
◷ 5 questions · 2-minute read

The Five Questions

Use these as a simple check before selecting, interpreting or relying on any assessment.

01Relevance

Is it measuring something the job actually requires?

Start with the role, not the test. Define the capability the job needs, then choose a method that can observe it.

Ask:Would this result help me make a better decision about this role?
02Consistency

Is the process consistent enough to compare people fairly?

Instructions, tasks and scoring should be comparable, so differences in results come from the people, not from the process.

Ask:Are we comparing candidates on the same basis?
03Evidence

What evidence supports the interpretation?

A score means little until you know what supports it: reliability, validity and benchmarks that fit this use.

Ask:What supports the conclusion we are drawing from this score?
04Experience

Does the candidate experience match the decision?

It should be understandable, accessible and proportionate. More assessment is not automatically better assessment.

Ask:Would a shorter or simpler process tell us enough?
05Accountability

Who remains accountable for the final decision?

Technology can process responses and surface signals. It should not remove accountable human judgment.

Ask:Who interprets the evidence and makes the final call?
“The strongest assessment professionals connect human behavior, evidence and a real decision — and know where the evidence stops.”
Tarvinder KaurCo-Founder, PMaps
Tarvinder Kaur, Co-Founder, PMaps

Keep the checklist with you

Share a few details and the one-page handout will download straight away. Save it for future hiring, assessment or research conversations.

Thank you! Your handout is downloading.

If the download doesn’t start, open the handout PDF here.

Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Preview of the one-page handout: Five Questions to Ask Before You Trust an Assessment

Continue exploring assessment science

The Association for Business Psychology

Don’t Start with AI, Start with the Problem

A practical look at why assessment and AI decisions should begin with the problem being solved, not the technology being used.

Read the article →
Event
JIBS Summit
O.P. Jindal Global University
15 October 2026
Talk
“The New Science of Talent Assessment: From Potential to Possibility”
Speaker
Tarvinder Kaur, Co-Founder, PMaps
Get a callback
Purple circular button with a white 'X' symbol in the center indicating close or cancel.

Get a Callback

Need support? Fill out the form and we'll get back to you shortly.

Get a Callback

Need support? Fill out the form and we'll get back to you shortly.

Valid number

Thank you!

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
You can check submitted datas from "Project Settings".
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
✓ Valid number